Art Imitates Life in Disturbing New Film

What you are about to read is disturbing.

It will unnerve you.

It should.

Orthodox. Faithful. Free.

Sign up to get Crisis articles delivered to your inbox daily

Email subscribe inline (#4)

Last week Under the Skin was released in the United States. This low budget British movie has little by way of traditional plot, even less dialogue. Some of it was shot with non-professional actors, at times using hidden cameras. Its director, Jonathan Glazer, has made only a handful of films. For all that, improbably, its lead is a Hollywood star, Scarlett Johansson. Initially, when it was shown in competition at last year’s Venice International Film Festival, it divided audiences. Nevertheless, on this side of the Atlantic it has appeared to ecstatic reviews—already being hailed as an instant cult classic.

It looks set to do well in the States and further afield.

Yet few will imagine the true horror lurking at its core. Neither had I, until that is a couple of weeks after the movie’s release when a news item surfaced. Only then, as these two distinct events snapped together in my mind, did I finally begin to understand what I had seen, and, more significantly, why, like some phantasm, it had haunted me since.

The film is loosely based on a novel by the same name, but the script has been pared-down to the bare bones of the book’s plot. In the end, what emerges is something very strange. From the opening shots accompanied by a hypnotic soundtrack, the audience is soon aware that this is no traditional movie. On one level it is pure cinema, unquestionably so; on an altogether different one, however, it appears to engage with something outside any source material, namely the collective unconscious of a nation.

Ostensibly, it is a Sci-Fi Horror movie hybrid about aliens. One in particular: an unnamed “woman,” played by Johansson, who drives a white van around Scottish streets and lonely country roads picking up solitary men before luring them back to various derelict houses. Thereafter, somewhere with ultra-bright white walls reminiscent of an operating room, they sink naked through the floor to a mysterious liquid chamber where they are held alive, until later that is, when a suction rips the men apart so that their body parts can be “recycled.” Or so it seems, as the “why” of all this is never explained. In fact, nothing much is explained. Relentlessly, the scene of hunter and hunted is repeated over and over again. Throughout the “woman” is aided by a sinister man on a motorcycle whose chief task appears to be the “clear up” [to clean up] after any disappearances. All of which is carried out in a brisk clinical fashion, and in silence.

Poster-art-for-Under-the-Skin_event_mainThere is one exception to this macabre modus operandi, however.

It is a beach scene: a cold, desolate Scottish one where the “woman” has gone to ensnare a young man who has been swimming. In the distance a family—mother, father and child—are seen. At this juncture, the intended victim becomes aware that the family are in difficulty: the mother is being swept out to sea with the husband’s attempts to save her failing. Immediately, the young man brushes aside the unmoved Johansson to help them.  As it transpires all three die, with the bodies soon after recovered and removed by the aliens. There then follows possibly one of the most chilling movie scenes of recent years.

As night falls and the bodies are forensically excised, there is someone left: the child. Unable to stand, it sits helpless on the rocky beach. Anxiously turning round, it starts to scream, looking bewilderedly for someone, anyone, as darkness descends and the waves grow ever closer. It is truly shocking.

What it is to be human and what it is to be inhuman, “alien,” caught in these few seconds of film.

That scene remained fixed in my mind for days after; in fact, I have not been able to free myself of it since. This is all the more baffling given that for decades now we as audiences have been exposed to, and got ever more used to, so much brutality of various kinds on screen.  Why then should this one scene disturb so?

The answer came in a news story just a few days later.

Art Imitates Life in UK
A recent undercover investigation on British television has revealed that the remains of aborted babies are being incinerated as “clinical waste” at UK hospitals, some burned with garbage to heat such facilities: at least 15,500 bodies have been so disposed of in the last two years alone.

On the suburban streets of Britain, with this modern day Gehenna, it seems that Moloch and Baal are once more being placated.

Perhaps it is stating the obvious to say that film captures something of its time; nevertheless, it is often more than we realize.

In its crudest form, one needs only to observe the latest piece of cultural propaganda being pushed to witness this, as whatever is “in the air” is then transferred onto the screen.  This process is both conscious and unconscious, however, and therefore at times will comprise what is being repressed as much as whatever is consciously revealed.

Is Under the Skin therefore a cryptic communication?

For here on display we have an expendable view of human life. Lives all too easily obliterated, with nothing left to say that a human being ever existed in the first place. In this movie, the victims are deliberately chosen because they are alone, and therefore vulnerable—with the expectation being that no one will look for or even miss them. Similarly, in today’s society, there are those that are rarely talked of as they, too, go missing. In fact, daily in the U.K. six hundred such souls disappear. That is the official number of abortions each day in this jurisdiction. And, now, we learn that what little had remained of those so killed ended up mingled with the dark plumes of smoke coming from the rear of the local hospital, no doubt at precisely the same time as, at its entrance, beaming mothers left to well-wishes holding their new born children.

Is it mere coincidence that at the end of this interminably bleak movie the audience is left in a remote isolated location with black smoke drifting upwards as the remains of an “alien” are set alight by a would-be rapist?

Whether it is that child stranded on the beach without any protection as night and swirling waves approach, or human beings helplessly suspended in liquid until used as body parts, or the final nihilistic ending—Under the Skin may be an unwitting testament to the very real darkness hidden at the core of British society.

  • K. V. Turley

    K.V. Turley is the National Catholic Register’s U.K. correspondent. He writes from London.

Join the Conversation

in our Telegram Chat

Or find us on

Editor's picks

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00

Orthodox. Faithful. Free.

Signup to receive new Crisis articles daily

Email subscribe stack

Share to...