The Murders in the Rue Morgue and Other Tales by Edgar Allan Poe

Edgar Allan Poe was missing.

The year was 1849.

There had been no trace of Mr. Poe for six days since he left Richmond, Virginia, on September 27th to travel back to his home in New York. His luggage was discovered at a Richmond tavern. Then, on the morning of October 3rd, he was found lying in a Baltimore gutter in great distress—beaten, delirious, and wearing clothes that were not his own. Edgar Allan Poe died four days later without recovering coherency. The cause of death remains disputed, involving theories that range from malady to murder. His last words were, “Lord, help my poor soul.” But that soul was lifted—nevermore!

Edgar Allan PoeThe mysterious death of Edgar Allan Poe has perplexed a world of detectives, which is morbidly fitting since Poe’s genius gave the world detectives. Poe is the father of the original detective story, The Murders in the Rue Morgue—and a better ancestor a genre of grotesqueries could not desire. Though The Murders in the Rue Morgue is the first to tread a path now so well trod, it stands at no disadvantage even by current standards. In all the horrifying and mystifying crime scenes ever conceived, the ghastliest would be hard pressed to eclipse what was found in the house in the Rue Morgue, Paris.

After being aroused at three o’clock in the morning by a series of shrieks, the neighbors forced their way into a fourth story chamber, all the doors and windows being locked from the inside. The room had been violently overturned and rifled, but nothing was stolen—not even the four thousand francs in gold scattered across the floor. Blood was spattered everywhere and a gory razor lay upon a chair. In the courtyard far below was found the body of an old woman—decapitated. Finally, the coup de grâce, the body of a young woman was also found—stuffed up the chimney, head downwards. The “Gazette des Tribunaux” summed it up well enough with this evening edition headline:

EXTRAORDINARY MURDERS

This headline arrested the attention of one of the most significant literary creations in history: Monsieur C. Auguste Dupin. Dupin is the father of Mr. Sherlock Holmes, the grandfather of Lord Peter Wimsey, the great grandfather of M. Hercule Poirot, and so his descendants run. Dupin is the first detective—the first of a beloved type: the eccentric genius who uses his powers of observation and deduction to beat the bumbling police at their own game; chronicled by a less-perceptive though loyal companion; and possessed with a taste for dramatic, eleventh-hour exposés. With Dupin and his brilliant unraveling of the mystery of the Rue Morgue, a pattern was created that humanity has not grown tired of yet and never will. The great analytical method of ratiocination founded by Poe and made famous by Conan Doyle is a joy even on its maiden voyage. Perhaps it is even more so, because it is always a particular pleasure to discover the peculiar origin of a standard phenomenon.

The Murders in the Rue Morgue is thematically applicable to much of Poe’s work—the struggle to see the light of truth and justice that shines at the end of a dark tunnel of violence and horror. This struggle dominates Poe’s tales of mystery, madness, and the macabre because it dominated his own tortured existence. Poe, for all his ugliness, believed in beauty; but he believed that beauty required a battle before it might be beheld. And those battles were not always won.

D. H. Lawrence once said that Mr. Poe was “doomed to seethe down his soul in a great continuous convulsion of disintegration, and doomed to register the process.” This statement drives at the significance of Edgar Allan Poe’s influence and unique literary contribution, though his writings are often dismissed as mere sensationalism, or modern gothic sideshows. Henry James, in the vein of such criticism, said: “an enthusiasm for Poe is the mark of a decidedly primitive stage of reflection.” The primitive stage, however, is an integral part of the human experience, both historically and individually, and does not deserve to be brushed aside. Everyone passes through a stage of adolescence—a stage of darker bents, psychological tempests, and self-doubt.

As childhood is doffed and the dark mantle of young adulthood is donned, perceptions shift to realms of solitude where truth has been somehow lost. The adolescent feels suddenly estranged, and often filled with longings for an immortal good that has not yet been reached. Beauty becomes inaccessible—the subject of impossible dreams and desires. The skies are shrouded by horror and the soul strangled by terror. This is the world of Edgar Allan Poe, and it is a world everyone must conquer.

Edgar Allan Poe’s “great continuous convulsion” speaks very naturally and very intensely to the adolescent spirit—passion, love, hatred, murder, primal desires and fears, a desperate pursuit for meaning in a corrupt world. The tales of Edgar Allan Poe capture a universal adolescent essence, and few things deserve to be taken as seriously as adolescence. Adolescence is a search. Adulthood is dealing with the discovery.

Poe’s tales, grim and brutal though they often are, provide an occasion to cope with the contradictions of the mind—so characteristic of adolescence—as it moves toward contemplation of metaphysical mysteries. Stories such as The Tell-Tale Heart and The Black Cat, poems like “Annabel Lee” and “The Raven” offer what T. S. Eliot called the objective correlative: a criterion to identify and objectify the experience of stirrings that are often too profound to bear. There is a dark side to our nature, and one way to defeat it is to face it. In this way, the tales of Poe afford an Aristotelian catharsis, giving form, meaning, and outlet to things that are naturally grappled with. Such experiences, jarring though they may be, can be therapeutic.

There arises in adolescents an added appetite for principles as well as for pleasures, and this is a quality to be retained. Adolescence teaches us to be both turned in on ourselves and observant of things. This double preoccupation is the effort to discover who we are and how we fit into our surroundings, deciphering the pit from the pendulum. The phantasms of Edgar Allan Poe’s imagination are potent material for such reflections, for his stories wrestle with who we are as human beings, engaged in the seemingly irreconcilable problem of evil. Poe, whether through M. Dupin or any other of his vast category of characters, is a guide to find that one, elusive end that will hold life together and be meaningful forevermore.

In the words of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, spoken on March 1, 1909, in honor of the centenary of Poe’s birth: “…his tales were one of the great landmarks and starting points in the literature of the last century… For those tales have been so pregnant with suggestion, so stimulating to the minds of others, that it may be said of many of them that each is a root from which a whole literature has developed.”

Sean Fitzpatrick

By

Sean Fitzpatrick is a graduate of Thomas Aquinas College and the Headmaster of Gregory the Great Academy. He lives in Scranton, PA with his wife and family of four.

  • Joanne S.

    “Adolescence is a search. Adulthood is dealing with the discovery.” Very nice, Mr. Fitzpatrick!

  • Kimberly

    As I am sure that it would cause I stir, but I would Love to have them do an autopsy or bone study on whatever remains are left to give us a better idea about what really happened to him.

    • Catherine

      I was a student nurse at the University of Maryland Hospital, many years ago. I often walked past a Protestant Church across the street from the hospital, and on the corner in front of the church is a moderately elaborate tomb wherein lie the mortal remains of Edgar Allen Poe. Or do they? Even when I was a student it was widely believed that the remains in the tomb, which had been moved from their original spot behind the church as Poe’s grave became a tourist attraction, belonged to some other poor soul.

      Years later I read an article, I believe in the Baltimore Sunday Sun, that related a possible scenario for what occurred, but I have never been able to find that article again, so I relate it from memory. Baltimore traffic patterns and the custom of that particular Protestant church at the time Poe was buried would have placed his body in a row of graves with modest headstones facing (for example) east. However, many years later, when the body of Mr. Poe was removed and placed in the more elaborate tomb, it was noted that his was the only grave marker in that close row that was facing the opposite direction. Some postulate that the grave had been robbed by Resurrectionists, likely from the medical school across the street (a common occurrance at the time). And in their haste to close the grave before being discovered, they placed the tombstone backwards. So the body in Poe’s tomb is possibly the body buried in the row behind him, and Poe’s body…possibly an anatomical display skeleton at the medical school? I always thought Mr. Poe would have approved that outcome. But after reading Mr. Fitzpatrick’s article, I am moved to whisper a prayer for his “poor soul”.

      • STF

        An eyewitness at the event of the author’s 1875 reburial notes that, although there was some difficulty in identifying Mr. Poe’s remains, a coffin was finally opened which yielded an unmistakable skull. “The skull was in excellent condition,” the witness reported. “The shape of the forehead, one of Poe’s striking features, was easily discerned.” I imagine that Mr. Poe’s poor soul would have taken at least some satisfaction in his skull being the instrument of his recognition.

        • Catherine

          Agreed. Thank you.

          • STF

            For we cannot help agreeing that no living human being

            Ever yet was blessed with seeing bird above his chamber door –

            Bird or beast above the sculptured bust above his chamber door,

            With such a name as “Nevermore.”

  • Pingback: 8 Things to Know and Share about Pentecost - Big Pulpit

MENU