• Subscribe to Crisis

  • Pope: St. Francis the model for dialogue with Muslims

    by Zoe Romanowsky

    In his audience last Wednesday, Pope Benedict spoke about the model St. Francis provides for dialogue with other religions, particularly Islam. Francis met in 1210 with the leading Muslim leader, Sultan Malik al-Kamil, in Egypt:

    “I want to underline this episode in the life of St. Francis because of its great relevance. At a time when there was a conflict between Christianity and Islam, Francis — armed only with his faith and his personal meekness — successfully followed the path of dialogue,” the pope said.

    St. Francis’ desire to speak to the sultan and the sultan’s cordial welcome is “a model that must inspire relations between Christians and Muslims today as well, promoting a dialogue in truth, mutual respect and understanding,” he said.

    Commonweal blogger Paul Moses, who wrote about Francis’s meeting with the Sultan in The Saint and the Sultan, found the pope’s words notable:

    What struck me is that the pope’s view of this encounter is similar to that taken by the Franciscan order, which sees the meeting between Francis and the sultan as source and inspiration to its emphasis on inter-religious dialogue. Benedict even uses that sometimes controversial word “dialogue.” That isn’t what I would have expected from someone who was put off by John Paul II’s Franciscan-influenced “spirit of Assisi” approach.

    Moses goes on to say that Benedict’s seems to reject St. Bonaventure’s account of the meeting Francis had with the Sultan. He further hopes the remarks will lead some to reconsider their approach to relations with Muslims. 

     

    The views expressed by the authors and editorial staff are not necessarily the views of
    Sophia Institute, Holy Spirit College, or the Thomas More College of Liberal Arts.

    Subscribe to Crisis

    (It's Free)

    Go to Crisis homepage

    • mark

      It would have been ideal zealous catholics religious
      and lay, could have gone to Gitmo to encourage, and offer
      example to the dedicated muslims.

    • Kamilla

      Zoe,

      Upon your earlier recommendation – I did go out and buy “The Saint and the Sultan”. It’s slowly working its way to the top of my bedside reading stack.

      Kamilla

    • Joe DeCarlo

      According to the New Testament, Christians are not supposed to associate with non-believers.

      • m parker

        How can the Gospel be spread then?

    • poetcomic1

      The violent, central teachings of Islam are immutable (and so dialogue is futile). Islam is inherently evil. It is not ‘another’ religion such as Hinduism or Buddhism. It is an outright diabolic distortion of both Judaism and Christianity. It is a true heresy of our faith. Islam is actively at war with Judaism, Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism, Atheism, Animism, Bahai and of course Muslims are daily busy killing other Muslims. It was is and always will be the enemy of humanity and most particularly the church which it openly despises.

      • Gigahoo

        True. But one has to distinguish between the religion and its adherents, who vary greatly in their adherence and interpretation, and openness to the truth. In Africa Christianity is converting the Muslims in large numbers. .

    • http://twitter.com/monomalomarin Alex M

      Jesus Christ died for Our Sins and this Sacrifice would never suffice if it were just another mere mortal suffering and dying due to his just punishment of Sin… Jesus is the New Adam, Jesus is the Help and Salvation of God, Jesus is the Son of God… God cannot be divided, Jesus is God… and God dying for Our Sins Suffices for Everlasting Life for those who choose it… We are not peddling philosophical belief systems folks, this is GOD SENDING PART OF HIMSELF TO DIE FOR US IN ORDER TO SAVE US, THIS IS GOD ACTING OUT A SPECIAL OPERATION TO SAVE THE HUMAN RACE… HELLO,…. To sit down and talk with Jews and Muslims about how a Christian can
      agree with an Anti-Christ has always dumbfounded me and made me prudent
      about any political rhetoric that gains little for the soul and
      everlasting life— God without Christ is too Superior for Salvation,
      Haven’t we heard the Holy Spirit, do we sin by rejecting it’s cry in the
      Wilderness… Alex Marin — Viva Cristo Rey